Best Reviewed Fitness Trackers under $425 of 2023

Overview

Decoder analyzed more than 74,893 reviews to find which fitness trackers under $425 are loved by shoppers, and which ones standout based on the following important qualities:

  • Battery Life
  • GPS
  • Heart Rate Monitoring
  • Activity Tracking
  • Sleep Tracking

Read more about what factors to consider when shopping for fitness trackers in our buyer's guide.

Results (28)

Best Overall

1

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is a great fitness tracker with a lot of features, but it has some inaccuracies that might be frustrating for some users.

Rank based on 7,730 reviews

Personalize Your Recommendation

Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve or the product you're looking for and our shopper assistant AI finds the perfect solution.

Also Great

2

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for an accurate and versatile device.

Rank based on 3,586 reviews

Premium Choice

3

Bottom Line

Overall, this is an amazing fitness tracker with great features that has helped many people improve their fitness levels. However, the battery life could be better and the sleep tracking could be more accurate.

Rank based on 3,857 reviews

Budget Pick

4

Bottom Line

The Fitbit Charge 3 is a great fitness tracker with accurate heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and sleep tracking features. However, the step tracker may be inaccurate and the watch's GPS features don't work well.

Rank based on 674 reviews

5

Bottom Line

The Fitbit Charge 3 is a reliable fitness tracker with good features for tracking progress and goals. It also has great battery life and GPS.

Rank based on 5,000 reviews

6

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for accuracy in heart rate, activity, and sleep tracking. The GPS is also user friendly and accurate.

Rank based on 1,562 reviews

7

Bottom Line

The Garmin Forerunner 235 is a reliable and accurate fitness tracker that is perfect for those looking to track their progress. However, some reviewers found the calorie and heart rate readings while working out to be inaccurate.

Rank based on 2,168 reviews

8

Bottom Line

The fitness tracker is a great way to monitor your heart rate, activity level, and sleep. However, the accuracy of the heart rate monitor and calorie data output may not be 100%, and the sleep tracker may not be accurate for everyone.

Rank based on 5,048 reviews

9

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for accuracy in heart rate monitoring and activity tracking.

Rank based on 1,509 reviews

10

Bottom Line

The device is great for tracking heart rate, sleep, and activity. The battery life is excellent, but the GPS design is clunky on the wrist.

Rank based on 4,927 reviews

11

Bottom Line

The heart rate monitor is cost effective, but inaccurate. The activity tracker is easy to use and accurate, but the step counter is not sensitive enough. The sleep tracking is close but often misses full sleep schedule.

Rank based on 1,480 reviews

12

Bottom Line

The Garmin Forerunner 235 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for accurate heart rate monitoring and sports tracking features. However, the sleep tracking is unreliable and the battery drains quickly when using GPS.

Rank based on 1,560 reviews

13

The Galaxy Watch4 is a fitness tracker that uses bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA) technology to track body composition. It is water-resistant, has advanced workout tracking, and can connect to live coaching sessions and Group Challenges.

Rank based on 2,011 reviews

14

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is an excellent fitness tracker for those who are looking for accurate heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and sleep tracking. The GPS provides a lot of features found on more expensive models, but the watch does not have all the features of those brands.

Rank based on 6,856 reviews

15

Bottom Line

While the heart rate monitor and sleep tracker might not be 100% accurate, this fitness tracker is a good option for those looking for an all-in-one device. The GPS is also pretty good, although there are some kinks.

Rank based on 1,984 reviews

16

Bottom Line

The Garmin Forerunner 235 is a great fitness watch for those looking for accuracy in their GPS and heart rate monitor. However, some users find the watch difficult to manage and the sleep tracking function inaccurate.

Rank based on 980 reviews

17

Bottom Line

Overall, this fitness tracker is great for heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and sleep tracking. However, there is a major discrepancy with the number of steps taken when compared to other fitness apps.

Rank based on 758 reviews

18

Bottom Line

Although the fitness tracker has some accuracy issues, the built-in GPS and activity tracking features make it a great choice for those looking for a solid workout companion.

Rank based on 502 reviews

19

Bottom Line

The Samsung Galaxy Watch Active 2 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for an accurate and reliable device. Though some features require a Samsung phone to work properly, the watch offers a variety of functions that are useful for tracking fitness and daily activity.

Rank based on 1,235 reviews

20

Bottom Line

This fitness tracker is a good choice for those looking for an accurate heart rate monitor, activity tracker, and sleep tracker. However, the device is not perfect and can be inaccurate at times.

Rank based on 1,826 reviews

21

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is a good fitness tracker with accurate heart rate monitoring, GPS, and decent battery life. However, some users find the sleep tracking and step counting features to be inaccurate. Additionally, the mobile app lacks substance.

Rank based on 2,050 reviews

22

Bottom Line

The Garmin Vivoactive 3 is a great fitness watch for those looking for a basic, yet effective device. It's got all the key features you need like heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and GPS, and it performs them well. It also has great battery life lasting over a week on a single charge.

Rank based on 1,548 reviews

23

Bottom Line

The fitness tracker is great for kids with its activity tracking, sleep tracking, and GPS features. However, some find that the band is not adjustable enough and that the sleep tracking could be more accurate.

Rank based on 2,047 reviews

24

Bottom Line

The TomTom Spark 3 is a great fitness tracker for those looking for accurate heart rate monitoring, activity tracking, and GPS. However, it lacks some features that other fitness trackers have and the battery life could be better.

Rank based on 2,417 reviews

25