Best Ice Cream Makers of 2023

Overview

Decoder ingested more than 27,937 reviews to find which ice cream makers are loved by shoppers, and which ones standout based on the following important qualities:

Freezing Speed
Ease Of Cleaning
Removable Bowl
Ice Cream Flavor

Read more about what factors to consider when shopping for ice cream makers in our buyer's guide.

Top 4 Recommendations

Best Overall

1

Cuisinart

ICE-21P1 1.5-Quart Frozen Yogurt

$69.95

Prime

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is perfect for those who want to make quick and easy batches of soft serve. The removable bowl means you can make multiple batches without having to clean and refreeze the bowl, and the fast freezing speed ensures that your ice cream will be delicious and creamy.

Rank based on 5,000 reviews

Also Great

2

Cuisinart

Ice Cream Maker by

$80.40

Prime

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is fast, easy to use, and produces consistently great results. Just make sure to give the bowl plenty of time to freeze before using it.

Rank based on 4,942 reviews

Budget Pick

3

Nostalgia

Electric Ice Cream Maker

$39.99

Prime

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is easy to use and clean, with good ice cream flavor. The main downside is that you need to pre-freeze the metal cannister or keep machine's freezer part in the freezer day-of use.

Rank based on 325 reviews

Premium Choice

4

Whynter

ICM-201SB 2.1 Quart Capacity Upright Automatic Compressor Ice Cream Maker

$331.50

Deal

Bottom Line

This machine is fast, easy to use, and produces delicious soft ice cream. Just remember to remove the mixing paddle from the bowl before extended freeze cycle.

Rank based on 477 reviews

Other Products to Consider

These are the remaining products that Decoder scored which are still pretty good, but not our top recommendations.

5

Cuisinart

ICE-21RP1 1.5-Quart Frozen Yogurt

$81.32

Bottom Line

A delicious ice cream maker that is quick and easy to use. However, the bowl must be frozen for 24 hours in advance and it is not dishwasher safe.

Rank based on 2,061 reviews

6

Cuisinart

Cusinart ICE-70P1 2-Quart Cool Creations Ice Cream

$145.29

Prime

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is fast, efficient, and produces great-tasting results. However, you must remember to freeze the bowl overnight and chill your ingredients beforehand.

Rank based on 1,375 reviews

7

Cuisinart

ICE-100 1.5-Quart Ice Cream and Gelato Maker

$287.99

Prime

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is perfect for those who want to quickly make a batch of delicious ice cream. It's easy to use and clean, with a removable bowl and lid. The flavor is excellent, with a soft serve consistency if you prefer to serve right away.

Rank based on 1,264 reviews

8

Hamilton Beach

68330N Automatic Ice Cream Maker

$48.00

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is fast and easy to use, with great tasting results. However, it doesn't freeze as well as other models and requires more ice.

Rank based on 2,125 reviews

9

Whynter

ICM-200LS 2-Quart Stainless Steel Automatic Ice Cream Maker With Compressor

$288.93

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

This machine makes excellent ice cream quickly and easily. However, the removable bowl is made of aluminum and ice cream sometimes drips below, making it necessary to clean out the whole machine.

Rank based on 653 reviews

10

Yonanas

902 Classic Vegan

Prime

Bottom Line

The Cuisinart ICE-100 is a great ice cream maker for those looking for an easy to use and clean machine. However, the freezing speed is a bit slow and it doesn't work well with taller bowls.

Rank based on 3,617 reviews

11

Nostalgia

Vintage Electric Ice Cream Maker

$49.99

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is incredibly fast and easy to use, but you must pre-freeze the canister and use cold ingredients for best results. Some customers have had trouble with the machine not freezing the ice cream properly, resulting in a slushy consistency.

Rank based on 866 reviews

12

Nostalgia

ICMP400BLUE 4-Quart Electric Ice Cream Maker

$60.03

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is quick, easy to use and clean, and produces great tasting ice cream. However, the bowl is made of thin aluminum and can be easily damaged.

Rank based on 1,067 reviews

13

Nostalgia

Electric Ice Cream Maker

$47.75

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

Perfect for those who want to make delicious and quick ice cream at home, this machine is easy to use and clean. However, some reviewers found the recipes to be too sweet.

Rank based on 798 reviews

14

Cuisinart

ICE-45P1 Mix-it-in 1.5-Quart Soft Serve Ice Cream Maker

$129.94

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker is easy to disassemble and clean, with many parts being dishwasher-safe. However, the removable bowl is difficult to clean and doesn't keep the ice cream cold enough.

Rank based on 1,827 reviews

15

Yonanas

988RD Deluxe Vegan Non-Dairy Frozen Fruit Soft Serve Dessert Maker

$72.21

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

This ice cream maker produces delicious and flavorful ice cream with a great consistency. It's easy to use and clean, but the freezing speed is a bit too slow for some customers.

Rank based on 282 reviews

16

Nostalgia

Electric Ice Cream Maker

$74.99

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a delicious ice cream flavor and a fast freezing speed, this is the ice cream maker for you. However, some users find that it takes a little longer than expected for the ice cream to freeze completely solid.

Rank based on 492 reviews

17

Nostalgia

Electric Ice Cream Maker

$39.99

Prime

Deal

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a fast and easy way to make ice cream at home, this machine is a great option. However, it doesn't always freeze the ice cream evenly and it's quite loud.

Rank based on 367 reviews

18

Elite Gourmet

Americana EIM-1400M 1.5 Qt Freezer Bowl Automatic Easy Homemade Electric Ice Cream Maker

$42.99

Prime

Bottom Line

The quick freezing speed of this ice cream maker is a major advantage, but the uneven freezing can be a bit of an issue. Overall, it's a great choice for those looking for an easy-to-use and clean ice cream maker.

Rank based on 399 reviews

Buyer's Guide

Written By

Decoder

Oct. 4, 20222 3:02 p.m. PT

Decoder is a product recommendation engine that eliminates the guesswork of online shopping and finds the perfect product for your needs.

Planning to buy an ice cream maker?

When buying an ice cream maker, it is important to consider a few things. The first is how much space you have. Ice cream makers come in all shapes and sizes, so you'll want to make sure you have enough room to store it. The next thing to consider is how much ice cream you want to make. Some ice cream makers are designed for small batches, while others can make large quantities. You'll also want to think about what type of ice cream you want to make. Some ice cream makers come with special attachments for making gelato or sorbet. Finally, you'll want to consider your budget. Ice cream makers can range in price from around $30 to $200.

Decoder generates product rankings at its discretion using proprietary methods. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Some of the content on this site comes from third parties. This content is provided 'as is' and is subject to change at any time.