Best Ice Makers of 2023 Reviewed

Overview

Decoder ingested more than 18,000 reviews to find which ice makers are loved by shoppers, and which ones standout based on the following important qualities:

  • Ease Of Use
  • Ice Quality
  • Water Filtration
  • Ease Of Cleaning
  • Ice Production Speed

Read more about what factors to consider when shopping for ice makers in our buyer's guide.

Results (19)

Best Overall

Prime Home Direct product image 6
Prime Home Direct product image 0
Prime Home Direct product image 1
Prime Home Direct product image 2
Prime Home Direct product image 3
Prime Home Direct product image 4
Prime Home Direct product image 5
Prime Home Direct product image 6
Prime Home Direct product image 0

1

Bottom Line

The ice maker is easy to clean, produces high quality ice, and has a fast production time.

Rank based on 983 reviews

Personalize Your Recommendation

Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve or the product you're looking for and our shopper assistant AI finds the perfect solution.

Also Great

ULIT product image 5
ULIT product image 0
ULIT product image 1
ULIT product image 2
ULIT product image 3
ULIT product image 4
ULIT product image 5
ULIT product image 0

2

Bottom Line

If you're looking for an easy-to-use and efficient ice maker that produces high quality, clean-tasting ice cubes, this is a great option. However, some reviewers say that it takes too long to produce ice and that the ice melts quickly if it's not used immediately.

Rank based on 1,750 reviews

Budget Pick

E EUHOMY product image 7
E EUHOMY product image 0
E EUHOMY product image 1
E EUHOMY product image 2
E EUHOMY product image 3
E EUHOMY product image 4
E EUHOMY product image 5
E EUHOMY product image 6
E EUHOMY product image 7
E EUHOMY product image 0

3

Bottom Line

This machine is praised for its ease of cleaning, fast ice production, and high quality ice cubes. However, some reviewers find it difficult to clean and the self-cleaning function ineffective.

Rank based on 599 reviews

Premium Choice

Gevi Household product image 7
Gevi Household product image 0
Gevi Household product image 1
Gevi Household product image 2
Gevi Household product image 3
Gevi Household product image 4
Gevi Household product image 5
Gevi Household product image 6
Gevi Household product image 7
Gevi Household product image 0

4

Bottom Line

This ice maker is easy to clean and produces high quality ice quickly. However, it needs to be cleaned frequently and can be difficult to clean by hand if not used with filtered water.

Rank based on 509 reviews

CROWNFUL product image 6
CROWNFUL product image 0
CROWNFUL product image 1
CROWNFUL product image 2
CROWNFUL product image 3
CROWNFUL product image 4
CROWNFUL product image 5
CROWNFUL product image 6
CROWNFUL product image 0

5

Bottom Line

This ice maker produces fast and efficient ice cubes, and is easy to set up and operate. The self-cleaning function is an added bonus for ease of cleaning.

Rank based on 1,130 reviews

CROWNFUL product image 7
CROWNFUL product image 0
CROWNFUL product image 1
CROWNFUL product image 2
CROWNFUL product image 3
CROWNFUL product image 4
CROWNFUL product image 5
CROWNFUL product image 6
CROWNFUL product image 7
CROWNFUL product image 0

6

Bottom Line

Overall, this is a great ice machine. It produces high-quality ice quickly and has an excellent water filtration system. However, it can be difficult to clean and some reviewers have had issues with the machine lasting more than a few months.

Rank based on 2,101 reviews

Mueller Austria product image 6
Mueller Austria product image 0
Mueller Austria product image 1
Mueller Austria product image 2
Mueller Austria product image 3
Mueller Austria product image 4
Mueller Austria product image 5
Mueller Austria product image 6
Mueller Austria product image 0

7

Bottom Line

This ice maker is easy to clean, quick and easy to set up, and produces top-notch ice. The self-cleaning feature and inline water filter are added bonuses that make this a great choice for those looking for a high-quality ice maker.

Rank based on 274 reviews

FREE VILLAGE product image 8
FREE VILLAGE product image 0
FREE VILLAGE product image 1
FREE VILLAGE product image 2
FREE VILLAGE product image 3
FREE VILLAGE product image 4
FREE VILLAGE product image 5
FREE VILLAGE product image 6
FREE VILLAGE product image 7
FREE VILLAGE product image 8
FREE VILLAGE product image 0

8

Bottom Line

Overall, this is a great ice maker with fast production speed and consistent, great-tasting ice cubes. However, some reviewers find it difficult to clean properly.

Rank based on 1,122 reviews

Igloo product image 6
Igloo product image 0
Igloo product image 1
Igloo product image 2
Igloo product image 3
Igloo product image 4
Igloo product image 5
Igloo product image 6
Igloo product image 0

9

Bottom Line

This ice maker is easy to clean, makes large, clean ice cubes quickly and easily, and has a good water filtration system.

Rank based on 535 reviews

Frigidaire product image 5
Frigidaire product image 0
Frigidaire product image 1
Frigidaire product image 2
Frigidaire product image 3
Frigidaire product image 4
Frigidaire product image 5
Frigidaire product image 0

10

Bottom Line

If you're looking for an ice maker that produces quality ice quickly and efficiently, this is a great option. However, it is noisy and requires regular cleaning.

Rank based on 1,336 reviews

Silonn product image 7
Silonn product image 0
Silonn product image 1
Silonn product image 2
Silonn product image 3
Silonn product image 4
Silonn product image 5
Silonn product image 6
Silonn product image 7
Silonn product image 0

11

Bottom Line

This ice machine produces clean, clear, and crisp ice at an incredibly fast speed. The self-cleaning cycle makes it easy to keep clean. However, some reviewers noted an unpleasant smell coming from the machine.

Rank based on 226 reviews

GE product image 9
GE product image 0
GE product image 1
GE product image 2
GE product image 3
GE product image 4
GE product image 5
GE product image 6
GE product image 7
GE product image 8
GE product image 9
GE product image 0

12

Bottom Line

A great ice maker that produces delicious, chewy ice. However, it can be noisy and slow, and is on the expensive side.

Rank based on 4,486 reviews

Thereye product image 5
Thereye product image 0
Thereye product image 1
Thereye product image 2
Thereye product image 3
Thereye product image 4
Thereye product image 5
Thereye product image 0

13

Bottom Line

Overall, this is an excellent ice maker with great ice quality and fast production speed. However, some machines arrived damaged or defective.

Rank based on 372 reviews

Frigidaire product image 6
Frigidaire product image 0
Frigidaire product image 1
Frigidaire product image 2
Frigidaire product image 3
Frigidaire product image 4
Frigidaire product image 5
Frigidaire product image 6
Frigidaire product image 0

14

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a fast and efficient ice maker with great ice quality, this is a great option. Just be prepared to clean it regularly and keep an eye on the ice level so it doesn't overflow.

Rank based on 676 reviews

E EUHOMY product image 6
E EUHOMY product image 0
E EUHOMY product image 1
E EUHOMY product image 2
E EUHOMY product image 3
E EUHOMY product image 4
E EUHOMY product image 5
E EUHOMY product image 6
E EUHOMY product image 0

15

Bottom Line

The NewAir AI-100R is a fast and easy-to-use ice maker that produces high quality ice. It's simple design makes it easy to clean, even with the auto clean function.

Rank based on 353 reviews

Frigidaire product image 2
Frigidaire product image 0
Frigidaire product image 1
Frigidaire product image 2
Frigidaire product image 0

16

Bottom Line

This ice maker produces quick batches of great-tasting ice, and the water filtration system ensures that the water is clean.

Rank based on 394 reviews

FREE VILLAGE product image 6
FREE VILLAGE product image 0
FREE VILLAGE product image 1
FREE VILLAGE product image 2
FREE VILLAGE product image 3
FREE VILLAGE product image 4
FREE VILLAGE product image 5
FREE VILLAGE product image 6
FREE VILLAGE product image 0

17

Bottom Line

This ice maker is quick and efficient, and produces high-quality ice. However, it must be cleaned at least once a week to prevent build-up.

Rank based on 228 reviews

Silonn product image 6
Silonn product image 0
Silonn product image 1
Silonn product image 2
Silonn product image 3
Silonn product image 4
Silonn product image 5
Silonn product image 6
Silonn product image 0

18

Bottom Line

This ice maker produces high quality ice quickly and has a self-cleaning function for easy maintenance.

Rank based on 388 reviews

Igloo product image 6
Igloo product image 0
Igloo product image 1
Igloo product image 2
Igloo product image 3
Igloo product image 4
Igloo product image 5
Igloo product image 6
Igloo product image 0

19

Bottom Line

This ice maker is easy to set up and use, and produces a large amount of ice quickly. However, the bucket can be difficult to clean and the machine does not have a long lifespan.

Rank based on 538 reviews

Buyer's Guide


Written By

Decoder

Oct. 4, 20222 3:02 p.m. PT

Decoder is a product recommendation engine that eliminates the guesswork of online shopping and finds the perfect product for your needs.

Planning to buy an ice maker?

When shopping for an ice maker, it is important to consider the unit's capacity, as well as how much ice it can produce in a day. It is also important to consider the unit's storage capacity, as well as its dimensions. Additionally, it is important to consider the unit's power consumption, as well as its noise level.

Decoder generates product rankings at its discretion using proprietary methods. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Some of the content on this site comes from third parties. This content is provided 'as is' and is subject to change at any time.

© 2022 DECODER | All Rights Reserved