Decoder analyzed more than 31,583 reviews to find which toaster ovens under $125 are loved by shoppers, and which ones standout based on the following important qualities:
- Exterior Finish
- Even Heating
- Ease of Cleaning
- Energy Efficiency
Read more about what factors to consider when shopping for toaster ovens in our buyer's guide.
Personalize Your Recommendation
Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve or the product you're looking for and our shopper assistant AI finds the perfect solution.
This toaster oven is a great choice for those looking for an even heat and energy efficiency. The pre-programmed settings make it quick and easy to use, and the removable crumb tray makes cleanup a breeze.
Rank based on 3,390 reviews
The Even Toaster Oven is a great choice for those looking for an energy efficient and stylish option. It's easy to clean, with a slide out tray, but the size can make it difficult to clean in tight spaces.
Rank based on 3,504 reviews
This toaster oven is a great choice for those looking for even heating, quick toast times, and easy cleanup.
Rank based on 1,246 reviews
The even heating, quick heat-up time, and energy efficiency make this toaster oven a great choice for those looking for an attractive and easy-to-use option.
Rank based on 3,067 reviews
The Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Toaster Oven with Roll-Top Door is a unique and convenient toaster oven with a large opening that makes food easy to reach. It has a roll-top door that opens above the oven, freeing up your countertop space in front, and is easy to keep clean.
Rank based on 1,208 reviews
The TOASTER OVEN comes with Even Toast Technology for perfectly toasted bread every time, as well as a sleek compact design that takes up minimal counter space. With a wide temperature range of 150-450 degrees Fahrenheit, you can cook a variety of dishes with the convenience of an oven.
Rank based on 4,352 reviews
The BLACK+DECKER Extra Wide Crisp 'N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven uses high intensity hot air to cook your favorite fried foods with little to no oil. With a large capacity that fits up to eight slices of bread or a 12" pizza, this toaster oven also has a 60-minute precision timer and three control knobs for easy use.
Rank based on 1,690 reviews
The Cuisinart 1800W Toaster Oven is a versatile appliance that can toast, bake, broil, and warm food. It has a 0.5 cubic foot capacity and can accommodate an 11" pizza or 6 slices of toast. The toaster oven has a stainless steel front with a cool-touch handle and an easy-clean nonstick interior.
Rank based on 532 reviews
Oct. 4, 20222 3:02 p.m. PT
Decoder is a product recommendation engine that eliminates the guesswork of online shopping and finds the perfect product for your needs.
Planning to buy a toaster oven?
When you are toaster oven shopping, consider how you will primarily use it. If you want to use it for simple tasks like toasting bread or reheating leftovers, a compact toaster oven may be all you need. But if you also want to be able to bake cookies or pizza, or even roast a chicken, you'll need a larger toaster oven with more power.
In terms of features, look for a toaster oven with an automatic shut-off timer, as well as an indicator light that lets you know when the preheating cycle is complete. Some toaster ovens also have a stay-on function, which can be useful if you're doing longer tasks like baking a casserole.
As for size, think about how much space you have on your countertop, as well as how many people you'll be cooking for on a regular basis. If you have a small kitchen and you're the only one eating, a compact toaster oven may suffice. But if you have a large family or entertain often, you'll need a larger model.
Finally, consider your budget. Toaster ovens can range in price from around $30 to $200. The most important thing is to find one that fits your needs and will last for many years to come.