Decoder analyzed more than 77,302 reviews to find which toaster ovens under $375 are loved by shoppers, and which ones standout based on the following important qualities:
- Exterior Finish
- Even Heating
- Ease of Cleaning
- Energy Efficiency
Read more about what factors to consider when shopping for toaster ovens in our buyer's guide.
Personalize Your Recommendation
Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve or the product you're looking for and our shopper assistant AI finds the perfect solution.
This toaster oven is a great choice for those looking for an even heat and energy efficiency. The pre-programmed settings make it quick and easy to use, and the removable crumb tray makes cleanup a breeze.
Rank based on 3,390 reviews
The Even Toaster Oven is a great choice for those looking for an energy efficient and stylish option. It's easy to clean, with a slide out tray, but the size can make it difficult to clean in tight spaces.
Rank based on 3,504 reviews
Overall, this is a great air fryer with even heating, plenty of interior space, and a sleek design. However, some reviewers found it difficult to clean around the heating elements and noted that the edges of the glass door were hard to clean of all crumbs.
Rank based on 3,311 reviews
This toaster oven is a great choice for those looking for even heating, quick toast times, and easy cleanup.
Rank based on 1,246 reviews
This toaster oven is perfect for those looking for an energy efficient option that heats up quickly and cooks food evenly. The removable crumb tray and easy-to-clean exterior make it a breeze to clean. However, the height limitation may be an issue for some.
Rank based on 572 reviews
This toaster oven is perfect for those who are looking for an easy-to-use appliance that heats up quickly and evenly.
Rank based on 1,845 reviews
The even heating, quick heat-up time, and energy efficiency make this toaster oven a great choice for those looking for an attractive and easy-to-use option.
Rank based on 3,067 reviews
The Instant Omni Pro is a countertop air fry toaster oven with 14 cooking functions. It features the innovative Split Cook feature, which lets you run two cooking programs or temperatures in sequence for perfect results. The Omni Pro also offers the quality, convenience and versatility you've come to expect from Instant.
Rank based on 2,361 reviews
This Toshiba toaster oven has 10 functions, a large interior, and comes with 6 accessories. It has a one-year warranty and lifetime customer support.
Rank based on 1,771 reviews
The Toshiba 25L Toaster Oven is a versatile and powerful countertop oven perfect for any home kitchen. With 1700W of power, two infrared heating elements, and convection cooking, this oven can easily cook a wide variety of both savory and sweet dishes. The digital menu display makes it easy to navigate the many functions and modes of the oven, and the included accessories (
Rank based on 1,762 reviews
The Cuisinart Chef's Convection Oven has 15 cooking functions and special settings for speed convection, sandwiches and bagels. With 1800 watts of heating power, it has a quick heat-up time and can precise temperature. The easy-clean nonstick interior is roomy enough to hold a 13-inch pizza, 9 slices of bread, a 9" x 13"
Rank based on 1,312 reviews