Best Reviewed Toasters under $125 of 2023


Decoder analyzed more than 39,426 reviews to find which toasters under $125 are loved by shoppers, and which ones standout based on the following important qualities:

  • Ease Of Use
  • Ease Of Cleaning
  • Bagel Function
  • Crumb Tray

Read more about what factors to consider when shopping for toasters in our buyer's guide.

Results (30)

Best Overall


Bottom Line

The bagel function is a great feature for this toaster, as well as the wide slots which can accommodate bagels or artisan breads. The defrost setting is also a nice touch. It takes awhile to learn the different settings, but once you do it's easy to use and clean.

Rank based on 2,090 reviews

Personalize Your Recommendation

Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve or the product you're looking for and our shopper assistant AI finds the perfect solution.

Also Great


Bottom Line

This toaster is perfect for those who love bagels. The wide slots make for even browning, and the defrost function is a bonus. The exterior is smudge and fingerprint resistant, making it easy to clean.

Rank based on 754 reviews

Budget Pick


Bottom Line

Despite the slightly messy crumbs, this toaster is very easy to use and clean. The bagel function is a nice touch.

Rank based on 1,204 reviews

Premium Choice


The Oster 2-Slice Toaster from the Metropolitan Collection is a stylish and versatile addition to any kitchen. With 9 unique shade settings, you can make toast just the way you like it. The bagel option automatically adjusts the toasting time for bagel thickness, and the defrost option takes bread from frozen to toast in one simple step.

Rank based on 163 reviews


Bottom Line

This is a great bagel toaster that perfectly and evenly toasts your bagels. However, the crumb tray is difficult to access.

Rank based on 1,774 reviews


Bottom Line

This toaster is a great choice for those looking for a sleek design with a small footprint. The bagel function perfectly toasts bagels on a low setting, and the wide slice function is great for frozen items.

Rank based on 1,715 reviews


Bottom Line

This toaster is easy to use, lightweight, and easy to clean with included brush and removable crumb tray. The bagel function works well, but some bagels may get stuck in the toaster.

Rank based on 1,223 reviews


Bottom Line

If you're looking for a toaster that will perfectly toast your bread, English muffins, and bagels, this is a great option. However, some customers found it difficult to clean.

Rank based on 3,383 reviews


Bottom Line

If you're looking for a toaster that can perfectly toast bagels with no burnt fingers, this is the one for you. It's also super easy to use and has a sleek design.

Rank based on 1,382 reviews


Bottom Line

This toaster is a great choice for those who want an easy-to-use and clean option with a retro look. The bagel function is a nice touch, but be aware that the coils on the inside of the toaster seem to break easily.

Rank based on 443 reviews


Bottom Line

If you're looking for an efficient and easy-to-use toaster, this is a great option. It toasts breads and other items evenly with no complaints about the function.

Rank based on 357 reviews


Bottom Line

If you're looking for a toaster that can evenly toast bagels and has a cool retro style, this is a great option. However, the slots are barely wide enough for bread.

Rank based on 1,016 reviews


Bottom Line

This bagel toaster is easy to use, with a touch screen and bagel function that toasts the inside of the bagel without burning the top. It's also easy to clean with a removable crumb tray.

Rank based on 286 reviews


Bottom Line

This toaster is a great choice for those who like to have freshly toasted bagels. It has a bagel function that toasts evenly on both sides and a crumb tray that is easy to clean.

Rank based on 903 reviews


Bottom Line

The bagel function is great for those who like their bagels toasted on both sides. However, the toaster doesn't always toast bread or bagels evenly.

Rank based on 1,595 reviews


This 4-slice toaster has extra-wide slots and dual independent control panels, making it twice as fast as a regular toaster. With 6 browning settings, it can accommodate different tastes. The defrost function thaws bread quickly, and the 100% stainless steel material is easy to clean.

Rank based on 324 reviews


Bottom Line

The bagel function is a great feature, and this toaster is overall simple to use. It's easy to clean with removable parts, but the crumb tray could be a bit larger.

Rank based on 665 reviews


This toaster has versatile toasting functions such as Toast, Bagel, Defrost, Reheat and Cancel. 6-setting shade dial offers a full range of browning options.

Rank based on 2,497 reviews


The Chitomax Toaster is a high-quality toaster that heats up quickly and evenly toasts bread on both sides. It is easy to use and clean, and features a cool-touch exterior, extra-wide slots, and 6 shade settings. The removable crumb tray and cord wrap make it easy to keep your kitchen clean and organized.

Rank based on 771 reviews


The Oster Jelly Bean 2-Slice Toaster is a toaster with advanced toast technology, extra-wide slots, and 7 shade settings. It is also customizable, with bagel, frozen, and pastry settings, and has a lift lever for easy retrieval.

Rank based on 3,050 reviews


This 4 slice toaster is made of high-quality stainless steel and has extra-wide toasting slots. It also has a built-in warming rack and can be divided into 2 zones with independent controls. Additionally, it has 4 functions (reheat, defrost, bagel, cancel) and 6 adjustable toasting levels.

Rank based on 243 reviews


Toast your favorite breads, bagels, and more with this KitchenAid 2-Slice Toaster. It features extra-wide slots to accommodate a variety of shapes and sizes, and the adjustable shade control lets you choose your desired level of toastiness. Plus, the high lift lever makes it easy to retrieve your toast.

Rank based on 2,639 reviews


Toast your favorite breads, bagels, and more with this two-slice toaster. With extra-wide slots, a bagel setting, and a defrost button, this toaster can handle a variety of items. The digital display and indicator lights make it easy to use, while the stainless steel design adds a touch of style to your kitchen.

Rank based on 613 reviews


The 4-slot toaster toasts bread, bagels, English muffins, and more quickly and evenly for perfect results each time. Choose from 6 browning settings for your favorite level of toasting. MULTI-FUNCTIONAL CONTROLS: The toaster has multifunctional controls for bagels, defrost mode, and quick-cancel.

Rank based on 599 reviews


The Elite Gourmet 4 Slice Long Slot Toaster is perfect for toasting a variety of breads, with extra wide and long slots to accommodate larger slices. It features 6 variable toast shade settings, as well as Cancel, Defrost, and Reheat functions, all housed in a sleek, modern, stainless steel design.

Rank based on 4,489 reviews


The Oster 2-Slice Toaster is a toaster with advanced toast technology for consistent results, extra-wide slots to accommodate various breads, pre-programmed toast and bagel settings, 7 shade settings, dual bread guides, a frozen setting, and a lift lever.

Rank based on 433 reviews


The GE Toaster is a durable 2-slice toaster that comes in a modern stainless steel finish. It features seven shade settings, a bagel setting, and a defrost function. The 850 watt toaster has a limited 1-year warranty.

Rank based on 415 reviews